flourish: A woman, Taura, whose face is a blend of human and beast: brown braided fur, fanged mouth set in a neutral expression. (Vorkosigan taura)
Flourish Klink ([personal profile] flourish) wrote in [community profile] vorkosigan2009-07-03 02:24 pm

"Mountains of Mourning" & The Vor Game

I fail at discussion-starting.

Any initial thoughts on these readthroughs? Here's a couple of mine:

Mountains of Mourning
  • This is the first time we actually learn about the Dendarii hill country, but it ultimately becomes pretty important in the series, both as character background for Miles and as a metaphor for Barrayar.
  • This is also the first time we learn about the extent to which Barrayar is filled with subsistence farmers. We've heard it before, but it's different to see it. Specifically, until now, we've seen Barrayar as a place that's essentially in the 20th century or a little advanced with regard to technology. Here, we see that those technological advances are actually very recent, and haven't filtered down.
  • How much is this based on Appalachia?
The Vor Game
  • Apparently, the US armed forces genuinely do have a place that's the equivalent of Kyril Island.
  • Is there something special about Miles' affinity for drains? Other than the fact that he's so small. I wonder whether his eventual Lord Auditor status could be considered the equivalent to being a "plumber," the "fix-it man." :P
  • It's so clear that this is the other half of The Warrior's Apprentice in theme, not just for Miles but for Gregor. Seeing Gregor in this book makes me regret very much that we don't get to see him in The Warrior's Apprentice.
  • Is Metzov intended as a dark mirror of Miles' father? 
What are your thoughts?

I should add: We press on on July 15 to Cetaganda and "Labyrinth," which I think are thematically connected enough to read together.

krait: a sea snake (krait) swimming (Default)

[personal profile] krait 2009-07-05 10:05 pm (UTC)(link)
Is there something special about Miles' affinity for drains? Other than the fact that he's so small. I wonder whether his eventual Lord Auditor status could be considered the equivalent to being a "plumber," the "fix-it man."

When I read this, I immediately thought of Peter Wimsey complaining that the Government is using him "as a plumber, to plug up diplomatic leaks".

We know Herself has read Sayers (a la the title of A Civil Campaign; maybe we're meant to catch the connexion? A bit of foreshadowing (in a way, Miles stops up the biggest potential "leak" of all when he finds the runaway Gregor; and as an Auditor he's going to be dealing with a lot of sticky political situations)?

Or at least a quiet underscoring of his relationship to the Imperium? After all, as Gregor's foster brother as well as -- now, anyway -- someone Gregor trusts, he's pretty uniquely placed for dealing with sensitive cases. He even uses this in Cetaganda as the explanation for his courier position/odd chain of command!

It's also something of a reminder that Miles can come "unplugged" -- Gregor, back in Warrior's Apprentice, distrusted Miles's motives and suspected him of treason. If he ever loses Gregor's trust/favour, his job and possibly even his life would be... "Depositatum De Latrina" (if I may borrow from another author for a moment)!
cjk1701: books with the label "iRead" (iRead)

[personal profile] cjk1701 2009-07-06 12:05 pm (UTC)(link)
*tries to stop thinking about Miles on the Discworld*

Barrayar as a country next to Quirm? Miles sent to sort out the political plumbing between Barrayar and Ankh-Morpork, and forced to deal with Sam Vimes and Lord Vetinari? Lady Alys meeting Sybil at the Quirm College for Young Ladies?
tree_and_leaf: Watercolour of barn owl perched on post. (Default)

[personal profile] tree_and_leaf 2009-07-27 01:18 pm (UTC)(link)
Ooh, that would be brilliant!